PAIRWISE COMPARISON
Rank choices
one pair at a time.
Pairwise comparison turns a long list into a series of smaller questions. Pick one purpose and judge every pair against it.
Which change most reduces delays at next month’s repair workshop?
Try the decision desk →Keep the question fixed
“Which idea is better?” may mean faster, cheaper or more useful to different people. Write the outcome and time window before comparing. For the workshop, imagine training a second host, adding an equipment checklist and setting up online booking.
Read a priority group
If the second host beats the checklist, and the checklist beats online booking, there are three levels of priority. The desk uses recorded wins and paths of wins to place options. Ties and deferred pairs create no win in either direction. Several options can share a group if the decisions give no basis to order them.
Review a circular preference
Now say online booking also beats the second host. A preference goes each way around the three choices. The desk keeps them together and names the cycle. Review the three comparisons and ask whether the group used the same outcome each time. Keep the cycle visible if the tradeoff is real.
Decide what should stay unresolved
Use “Even” when two options serve the stated goal equally well. Use “Decide later” when evidence is missing or the group needs a conversation. The comparison record keeps those decisions visible.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory research on pairwise methods ↗